A study published in connection with the Harvard Kennedy School earlier this month found that university students and government nurses in Bangalore, India who cheated on a simple task were more likely to want government jobs.
The study was conducted by economists Rema N. Hanna, an associate professor at the Kennedy School, and Shing-Yi Wang, an assistant professor at the Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania. The paper is affiliated with the Center for International Development at the University.
The students who participated in the study were chosen randomly, while the nurses worked for the government and were selected based on their participation in a previous study on their absences from work.
During the study, the participants were asked to roll a standard die 42 times and self-report their own score. The researchers determined the prevalence of lying by comparing the participants’ answers with the median score for dice points.
According to the study, nurses who were above the sample median of dice points were 7.1 percent more likely to be fraudulently absent than those below it. In addition, students who cheated on the dice game were then 6.3 percent more likely to want a government job.
The study concludes that a relationship exists between students lying on the dice test and their desire to go into public service and nurses lying on the dice test and their dishonesty about their reasons for missing work.
Though the study may have some implications for those who wish to enter public service in certain countries, Wang said in an email to The Crimson that the results do not necessarily apply outside India. She added that her motivation for the study was based on what she has seen in developing countries, though similar tests outside of India would make for interesting follow-up research.
Similarly, Jane J. Mansbridge, a professor at the Kennedy School who studies political leadership, said in an email to The Crimson that study does not hold much weight outside of “situations where there were good opportunities for corruption.”
Though Mansbridge is not affiliated with the researchers’ work, she had read the study and said that the findings are not necessarily applicable in places like the United States, where there is not much opportunity for corruption at the state or federal level of government.
Read more in News
Harvard Researchers Discover Mortality Benefits of Nut ConsumptionRecommended Articles
-
Milk and Vitamin D Intake May Help Prevent MSConsuming milk and a high dietary intake of vitamin D while pregnant may lower children’s risk of developing multiple sclerosis later in life, Harvard researchers find.
-
POSTCARD: How Not to Find French Housing -
Boston Medical Center Announces LayoffsBoston Medical Center announced in a statement released Monday that it would lay off 119 staff members in order to make up for a projected $175 million loss due to “dramatic changes in Medicaid reimbursements.”
-
Study: Link Between Depression and DiabetesResearchers at the Harvard School of Public Health have discovered a relationship between depression and type 2 diabetes, two serious conditions in the United States.
-
Closing the HKS Gender ImbalanceIn spite of efforts to raise awareness on the issue of gender imbalance, the percentage of female faculty at the Kennedy School—although improving from year to year—has remained very low over the past decade.
-
Harvard Professors, Students React to Congress' Cuts to Planned Parenthood FundingHarvard professors and students have expressed a variety of opinions about a controversial measure to cut federal funding to Planned Parenthood approved by the Republican-controlled House of Representatives last Saturday.
