And critics argue not only against the technique itself, but also against its practitioners, whom they characterize as "imperialists" and, they say, whose interest in undergraduates is often as low as student interest in their highly quantitative subject matter.
"It's dispassionate, and many students enjoy politics for its passion," Shepsle concedes. "You have to be capable of suspending your passion. That may make it more boring, but that's life."
Divide and Conquer
But critics of rational choice say that the movement's forerunners had a very different modus operandi.
Whereas the behavioralists managed to blend into the rest of the department fairly well, rational choicers are accused of a cultishness in which they have come to exert undue control over Harvard's--among others'--Government Department.
"They do tend to evaluate all other political scholars on whether or not they are rational choice theorists," says former Harvard government professor James Q. Wilson. "They have not learned to be humble."
Recent tenure controversies, in the government department in particular, have underscored the difficulty scholars encounter in trying to navigate Harvard's tenure system, facing ad hoc committees that many on the Faculty characterize as whimsical.
Read more in News
Mayor Advocates Wage IncreaseRecommended Articles
-
A ROTC SolutionFor an institution which prides itself on being the premier educational institution in the world and one that values toleration,
-
Citizens' Apathy FrighteningTo the editors: The reactions to the impeachment process expressed by Erin Ashwell (Letters, Dec. 14) and The Crimson's editorial
-
Let's Be Sane About This DebateThis evening I had the opportunity to peruse the latest Peninsula issue. I say opportunity because at an institution which
-
SHOCKLEY'S RIGHTSTo the Editors of The Crimson: "Freedom of speech" cannot be invoked to defend William Shockley against those who forced
-
Dissent DecorouslyF ace it--General Colin Powell is going to speak at Harvard's 357th Commencement whether you like it or not. The
-
The Art of Making People ThinkA ssuming the role of Emily Post for campus discourse, Evan P. Cucci advanced his view of what constitutes responsible