To the editor:
As a Jew with a deep bond with the state of Israel, I was saddened and ashamed to watch as the Israeli army killed hundreds of Palestinian civilians in the Gaza Strip this summer, and even more so to witness the reactions of many in the Harvard community as students publicly grieved these injustices.
In a letter to the editor Thursday, my classmate David F. Sackstein ’14 wrote that the Palestine Solidarity Committee’s use of the word “massacred” in its demonstration last Monday makes it “difficult to view the citizens of Israel as human beings that share with many Palestinians their yearning for a peaceful future.” I could not disagree more. We should not be afraid to call injustices committed against Palestinians what they are. Doing so does not demonize the Israeli people any more than admitting any injustice demonizes the people whose leaders committed it. Criticisms of Monday’s demonstration, like those in The Crimson’s dissenting staff editorial Friday, for its lack of nuance or “one-sidedness” miss the point. The PSC did represent one side—the side of Palestinian people—and it’s a side every bit as true as an Israeli’s. Rather than shut down conversation we should be listening closely and affirming Palestinians’ experiences.
I experienced a great deal of doubt before deciding to write this letter for fear of offending members of the Jewish community. It shouldn't have to be this way. I am not among a minority but a silent majority of progressive Jews growing increasingly uneasy with Israel's administration. I am like my peers invested deeply in the future of Israel, my second home and the home of my family members. Criticism of Israeli policy does not pose an existential threat to the Jewish people or to Israel. To the contrary, silencing Palestinian suffering does.
Marina N. Bolotnikova ’14
Crimson Editorial Chair Emerita
Read more in Opinion
Dissent: Moral NonequivalenceRecommended Articles
-
Israel vs. No. 2 PencilsAs countless students around the world took the SAT a week ago, Palestinians from the West Bank could not join their ranks. The October SAT exam was cancelled for students in the West Bank: The Israeli authorities held the exams sent by the College Board for weeks, not releasing the tests to AMIDEAST’s office in Ramallah.
-
White Israelis, Brown PalestiniansThe daunting challenges we face are political, military, and economic in nature. To invent a racial dimension blows open an additional chasm between our peoples, setting back the enterprise of coexistence yet another step.
-
The Wrong Side of HistoryIt is time for America to do the right thing and work toward establishing a state of Palestine, even if that means ignoring the more aggressive demands of Israel.
-
Always on the Side of the EggIsrael and Palestine are nervous lovers who have not yet come to grips with the weakness and humanity of the other.
-
Carr Center Speakers Express Disapproval of Israeli-Palestinian Water DistributionCalling for comprehensive solutions to the water crisis in the West Bank, Tufts professor Annette Huber-Lee and Palestinian refugee Nidal al-Azraq presented work on improving Palestinian access to adequate safe water at an event hosted Thursday evening by the Kennedy School’s Carr Center for Human Rights Policy.
-
No Racism on the T“In any war between the civilized man and the savage, support the civilized man. Support Israel; defeat Jihad.” So reads an advertisement from the American Freedom Defense Initiative, an organization that spews equally racist rhetoric across the country. After the MBTA rejected the proposed advertisement because it violated rules that ads could not be “demeaning or disparaging,” the AFDI filed a lawsuit against the transit agency.
