At the heart of Harvard's argument is the fact that Berkowitz amended his complaint this fall, and included information about the list of scholars that he was compared to by his ad hoc tenure committee.
Berkowitz says the scholars were all farther along in their careers than he was, and thus should not have been on the list.
Harvard says that, because this matter was never pursued through its internal grievance system, the court should not rule on the matter--even though Berkowitz just learned of the names recently, well after the internal grievance review was completed.
"We believe that the court's decision is wrong in a fundamental way," said University spokesman Joe Wrinn. "And we think that the issues are so important in this case that it warrants the review we are seeking in an appellate court."
Legal experts familiar with the Massachusetts court system say Harvard's appeal--called an interlocutory appeal--is highly unlikely to be approved, especially by a judge who has ruled for Berkowitz twice before.
"Interlocutory appellate review is an extraordinary remedy. It's an extraordinary recourse to be used if the mere carrying forward of the lawsuit is going to inflict irreparable damage," said Harvey A. Silverglate, co-founder of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE).
"They're in desperation mode now. If they don't do something to stop discovery all their secrets will be out," he added.
Read more in News
Speakers Discuss Gay Experience in AthleticsRecommended Articles
-
Psychiatry Board Alleges Professor Lied On ResumeThe American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology (ABPN) has filed suit against Dr. Gloria Johnson-Powell, a professor of psychiatry at
-
Berkowitz's Claim Found "Clearly Without Merit"After nearly five months of deliberation, the elected members of the Faculty's Docket Committee have issued their judgment in the
-
Berkowitz, Harvard Face Off In CourtHarvard moved Wednesday to dismiss a lawsuit brought against the University by a professor denied tenure two years ago. Former
-
Judge Denies Move To Dismiss Berkowitz SuitFor the first time in its history, Harvard may have to release confidential internal documents from a tenure case, now
-
Tenure Suit Sent to Appellate CourtHarvard prevailed in a last-ditch effort to protect the secrecy of its tenure process when a Mass. superior court judge
-
Harvard Argues For Dismissal Of Tenure CaseBOSTON—Harvard made one last effort to keep its tenure process secret yesterday, arguing before a Massachusetts state appeals court that