"Nobody from our class was on this committee," he said. "Why didn't they wait for our class to come in to be able to represent themselves?"
Lewis wrote, though, that such a decision process would create significant instabilities in Harvard policy.
"If that were the correct way of doing things, then by the same logic it would seem that we ought to reconsider every Harvard rule annually with input from the students they affect," Lewis wrote.
Lewis added that students who had been at Harvard for a longer time would have a better perspective on the tradeoffs of such a decision.
"Petitions are never a good way to deal with issues that have to do with limiting choices or expanding requirements--as individuals we would always vote to give ourselves more choices and fewer requirements," Lewis wrote.
"That's why the process for understanding such choices is through reasoned discussion in student-faculty committees, not petitions," Lewis added.
The arguments for and against smaller maximum blocking-group sizes are varied. Quincy House Master Michael Shinagel wrote in an e-mail message that, after randomization, "each House should be a 'microcosm' of the College in terms of diversity."
Read more in News
FAS Appoints New Associate Dean of FinanceRecommended Articles
-
Randomization Creates Larger Blocking GroupsFirst-years will trudge to the Science Center today to submit their blocking forms for the first fully-randomized housing lottery in
-
Blocking Group Size Angers FewOne week after the College announced it would reduce the maximum size of blocking groups from 16 to eight, student
-
House Community in JeopardySurrounding the news of the Administration's cut in blocking groups size floats a nebulous idea: "House community." The Masters say
-
'Blocking' Student PetitionsFor first-years, today marks the first day that blocking group preference forms can be filed online. It also marks the
-
Smaller Blocking Groups Encourage Stress, Strain FriendshipsThe last first-year students handed in their blocking group forms in the basement of the Science Center yesterday in an
-
The Death of the HousesThursday will be a turning point in the Harvard experience for the Class of 2003. They will see how the
