In his final appraisal, Crichton-Stuart valued the painting at $100,000.
Christopher T. Apostle, an expert on old master paintings at Sotheby's, said he disagreed. "While all the old documents said it was a copy, when I saw the painting I realized it was high quality and from the 16th century," he told the Times.
He also said the curators from the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, the National Gallery in London and an independent Italian scholar were all convinced it was an original from del Sarto. On NBC's "Today" show, Mr. Apostle restated his opinion. "It's in very good condition," he said.
Shearman, who is well-connected in art circles, wrote a letter to Sotheby's in early December, saying he doubted the painting was wholly authentic.
"Without question, it comes out of his workshop," Shearman said in an interview.
He said the painting's outer layers were likely painted by one of del Sarto's assistants, while the master etched the figures beneath.
As soon as he reached his conclusion, "I told them about my findings as soon as I saw the painting in early December," he said.
Read more in News
Harvard Current Reports McCain Ad Found on Porn SiteRecommended Articles
-
Gates Family Train Trip Across Africa Featured in Book, Television SeriesWhile many students spent the summer working in air-conditioned office buildings, DuBois Professor of the Humanities Henry Louis Gates Jr.
-
Shearman Named University Prof.Boardman Professor of Fine Arts John K.G. Shearman, a scholar of Renaissance art, has been named a University professor. Shearman,
-
Fine Arts to Offer Koerner TenureThe University will extend a tenure offer to Assistant Professor of Fine Arts Joseph L. Koerner, department members said yesterday.
-
Surveying the History of ArtThree years ago, the Fine Arts Department killed its most popular class. Students liked the course, but faculty did not.
-
No HeadlineThe points won by the cootestants in the high-jumping tournament at Yale are as follows: Bayard, 29; Knapp, 28; Shearman,
-
The Yale All Round Sports.There were ten entries for last Wednesday's Yale sports which were held to determine the best all round athlete in
