Observers listening to the justice's questions could not predict which side had the edge. If the court reverses the state's decision, the Bush campaign hopes that Gore's challenges will lose needed momentum, particularly in the court of public opinion. Most polls show the country evenly split as to whether a speedy resolution is preferable to a full deliberation of all the disputes. An ABC News/Washington Post poll found that 80 percent of Americans would support whichever candidate is inaugurated on Jan 20.
Many court observers were surprised that the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case at all, said David L. Shapiro '54, HLS's Cromwell professor of law.
"Most law professors were surprised. I think if you had taken a vote about whether the court would take the case, most people would have said it wouldn't," he said.
But Shapiro said the decision was not without precedent.
"There have been times before when the court has taken issues of great national significance on short notice," he said, referring to the Pentagon Papers case.
"There are precedents for taking cases of great national importance even though they haven't percolated in the lower courts--especially if there is significant time pressure," he said.
Shapiro also observed that the court requires a majority vote of the justices to bring a case up for argument.
Read more in News
A Different ToneRecommended Articles
-
Florida Supreme Court Hears Both Sides in Election CaseThe future of the presidential election now lies in the hands of the seven members of the Florida Supreme Court.
-
Taking Off the BlindfoldPerhaps we should have known it was too good to be true. Last Friday, the Florida Supreme Court, by a
-
Supreme Court Hears Recount ArgumentsAfter five weeks of legal wrangling, the end is finally near. Lawyers for Vice President Al Gore '69 and Texas
-
LettersDonors Don't Neglect Humanities To the editors: The premise of your editorial (Dec. 4), that humanities and social science departments
-
Deeply Divided Supreme Court Rules for BushA bitterly polarized U.S. Supreme Court effectively ended the presidential hopes of Al Gore '69 last night, reversing a Florida
-
Bittersweet VictoryWith last night's concession by Vice President Al Gore '69, the most tumultuous election of modern times finally came to