Bartholomew broke a 60-yard run on Yale's next drive and set up a another pass from Lee to Johnson to put the Bulldogs up 14-7.
Fordham and her fans got back into the game, scoring on a field goal and a 18-yard TD pass from Mucci to wide receiver Kendal Creer to put Fordham ahead 17-14.
Fordham also stopped Yale on its next possession, but the Elis would put together a 58-yard drive, 44 of those yards gained by Bartholomew, that culminated in a three-yard Bartholomew TD run. Yale added a field goal with 3:16 remaining to help seal the victory.