Although one might argue that one of the premises, the idea that Tillie would create an science fair-winning set of marigolds which had been exposed to certain types of radiation, is somewhat implausible, the scenes of the play focus not on such plot-driving points, but on the interactions between Tillie's bitter, estranged mother (Stotland), Tillie and her sister Ruth (Jamie Smith '02).
Nothing within this framework of family drama warrants Yellen's use of frequent and distracting mid-scene lighting changes, loud and obtrusive background music (respectably written by Martijn Hostetler '00, who is surely not to blame for the placement of his work) at already obvious emotional high points, and acting that focuses more on the audience and the treatment of the lines than the character within.
The element of the production that does live up to the naturalism implicit in the script is the set, brilliantly designed by Pete Wilson '99. The odd assortment of knickknacks, broken down furniture, and trash evokes the chaos and turmoil in ways that many of the performances, alas, do not.
The shining exception to this is the work of Smith as Ruth, who intelligently centers her performance on the identity of her character and delivers her lines as the character. Stotland is not so fortunate--she rarely transcends a simple line-reading and performs with little emotional variation, save a certain modulation of volume with which she attempts to point out to the audience which lines are important.
The actors may have fared better had the makeup design made some pretense of realistically defining the characters' ages. Alas, the audience is thus left to wonder how Stotland could possibly be the mother of Jump and Smith, save for the fact that she walks more slowly and speaks without the breathy, childish tone that Jump seems to mistake for the way high school students actually speak.
It is clear at many points during the evening that the actors have been instructed to play for laughs. In some cases, their attempts are even convincing. Note, for example, the physical comedy employed by Dale Shuger '00 as Nanny, the old woman that Beatrice houses and takes care of, abusing her all the while. Or see Carrie-Anne Dedeo's '00 delivery of her one moment in the show, a surprisingly funny monologue in the form of a science fair presentation. One could easily question, though, whether these moments contribute to the flow of the piece, or whether they simply stand in the way of the emotional void at its core.
It frequently appears that the director is in flight from the severity of the family relationships that comprise the bulk of the script. It is plausible that with an expert ensemble and less sluggish staging and pacing, this play might present the possibility for some very comic moments.
Read more in Arts
Where There's SmokeRecommended Articles
-
Late in the Game: Life as a Mature Harvard StudentWhile most Harvard first-years are just beginning to exercise their 18-year-old voting rights, others are already veteran participants in the
-
HLS Says Globe Inflated Plans for Class ReformDespite news reports of a policy overhaul at Harvard Law School (HLS), plans for student life reform are still in
-
Law School Plan Cuts Class Sizes, Adds 'Colleges'In an effort to address quality-of-life concerns voiced by its students, Harvard Law School (HLS) will slash lecture sizes and
-
Skeletons Have No Soul"I GOT STUCK with one daughter with half a mind; another one who's half a test tube; half a husband--a
-
The Suppressed Side of CreativityT HE EYES on the bookjacket portrait look into yours and seem to know you. They are kind, sad, wearied
-
The Survival of Tillie OlsenI F YOU had been one of the people in the crowd which packed Longfellow Hall last Wednesday night, you