If the impending Congressional probe into the Harvard Medical School's use of federal overhead funds reveals any wrongdoing, the University may lose more than just hundreds of thousands of dollars.
The University could lose face, and the Medical School may lose ground in ongoing negotiations for a new "indirect cost" rate with the Department of Health and Human Services.
A similar federal probe at Stanford University led to an aggressive criminal investigation by the Naval Investigation Service (NIS).
And discoveries that administrators misappropriated federal funding may lead to a reevaluation of their rate of government reimbursement for indirect costs--expenditures that are meant to be connected with grant research needs.
Stanford has one of the highest indirect cost rates in the country. Harvard Medical School currently has the highest such rate.
As of December 26, NIS has been "aggressively looking into criminal allegations of criminal misconduct" at Stanford, according to a member of the House Oversight and Investigations subcommittee, the team that is investigating Stanford and will begin a similar probe at the Medical School in March.
At Stanford the subcommittee found the university had tagged as indirect costs such expenses as the depreciation on a 72-foot yacht and floral decorations for the home of President Donald Kennedy '52. Stanford has agreed to pay back nearly $700,000 to the government, said the investigator, who spoke on condition of anonymity.
If similar discoveries are made at the Medical School, a criminal investigation could follow, bringing embarrassment to the University with it. The subcommittee member said the team currently has no evidence of misconduct at the school.
Harvard has not been officially notified of the probe, according to the subcommittee member and University News Office Director Peter Costa.
"We have had no indication about any federal investigation," Costa said. "It's speculation right now."
"We wait for offical notification," Costa said. The federal investigator said the University would likely be notified "when the investigation begins," which could be as early as March 1.
If a probe uncovers any improprieties, the Medical School could also lose strength in its negotiating stance for an increased indirect cost rate with the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).
The school now has a provisional indirect cost agreement with HHS of 88 percent, in effect since July 1.
This means that for every dollar that the government awards the Medical School in grant monies, the University is entitled to an additional 88 cents, which is meant to reimburse research-related costs. Indirect costs can include expenses such as lighting, heating, renovating laboratories and building new research buildings.
In the 1990 fiscal year, the University received over $18 million from the National Institute of Health (NIH) in reimbursement for indirect costs for the Medical School, according to Robert F. Moore, supervisory program analyst for the division of research grants at NIH.
Read more in News
New Abortion Battle Heats Up