A plan which turns management of one of the most impoverished school districts in the metropolitan area over to Boston University (B.U.) continues to draw fire from community members nearly one month after its initial implementation.
The transferring of the Chelsea schools to B.U. for 10 years marks the first time in U.S. history that a private university has run a public school system. B.U. officials hope that the plan will become a model for urban educational reform.
But B.U. faces a daunting task in improving the Chelsea school system. Students from the district have tested among the lowest in the state for basic skills. The average annual income for a Chelsea household is $10,000, and the teenage pregnancy rate for Chelsea students is one of the highest in the state.
While many Chelsea residents have welcomed B.U.'s help, some community groups have argued that B.U. and the Chelsea school commission have not sought enough community input on the new set-up.
The privatization plan is facing two lawsuits, one from a teachers union arguing that the plan does not allow for enough public oversight and thus violates the state constitution, and another from Hispanic parents charging that city officials did not give the community adequate opportunity to respond to the plan before formally adopting it.
B.U. officials have denied the charges, saying they have tried to gain parents' opinions every step along the way.
B.U. President John Silber said that the claims that there has been a lack of community input are "not credible," citing "the number of consultations that have been made."
"[The questioning of B.U.'s accountability] obscures the fact that B.U. has signed a contract with a publicly elected school committee that candismiss B.U. at any time by a simple majority voteand to whom B.U. reports and consults at regularintervals," Silber said in an interview with TheCrimson yesterday.
B.U. officials said that they hoped to turn asignificantly strengthened school system back overto Chelsea in 10 years.
"I would hope that Chelsea would maintain itand not let it slip back," said Peter Greer, deanof B.U.'s School of Education. To this end, hesaid, "We have to build in structure to everythingwe do." The School of Education is nowadministering the schools, although the plan wasoriginally developed by the School of Management.
Despite B.U.'s grand plan for the Chelseaschools, some city residents have criticized theprocess that led to the historic arrangement.
The Chelsea Commission on Hispanic Affairsobjected to the initial lack of informationalmaterials printed in Spanish. The group alsocriticized the B.U. plan for not providing forbilingual education in the early childhood years.Approximately 52 percent of Chelsea's 3400students are Hispanic.
'Let's Be Partners'
"Educational reform should not come about inthis paternalistic approach," said Marta Rosa,president of the Chelsea Commission on HispanicAffairs and a candidate for the area's schoolcommittee. "If it's being called a partnership,then let's be partners."
B.U. has also faced questions aboutaccountability in its actions and use of funds.
Read more in News
Transfer Student Quotas End; Policy Depends on Dorm Space