Advertisement

Clarence Darrow of Brooklyn

Riddle: Who has defended more civil liberties cases before the U.S. Supreme Court than any other lawyer and smiles like a Jewish grandmother?

Leonard B. Boudin is the name. And the man's legal defense record is an impressive march through American social history; starting with labor leaders in the thirties, to alleged Russian spies in the forties, past anti-McCarthyites in the fifties, and onto Spock, Berrigan, and Ellsberg in the last decades.

Yet outside of legal circles and an occasional mention somewhere in a New York Times article, you don't run into the name very often.

Boudin's appearance certainly doesn't overwhelm anybody. He's on the small side, and heavy bags under his eyes make him look tired. His gray-white hair, once blond, is short but disheveled, and his simple sports coat and sweater are more the dress of a recluse academic than a senior law partner with a 10-room office in downtown New York.

And let us not forget the Jewish grandmother in Boudin. The second he opens his mouth he betrays his Brooklyn upbringing. If you catch him in a relaxed social setting you may run into a trail of babble which is not the least bit blemished by transitional ideas: "I got into this cab today, and the cab driver has a December 3rd Newsweek--that's all right but it would have been nicer if it were December 10...I read papers, magazines, deep books, anything I can get my hands on. (What deep books, Mr. Boudin?) Well, I never read a deep book. But I am writing a novel, though I still haven't written a word--it's all in my head."

Advertisement

There's a lot in that Boudin head, accumulated from a legal career that has touched five decades. The son of a real estate lawyer, Boudin attended the City College of New York and graduated from St. John's Law School where he was an unexceptional B student. His uncle, a well-known constitutional lawyer in the '30s, took him into the firm, starting Boudin on union cases.

Boudin feels his work in the passport cases of the fifties gave him his strong civil liberties orientation. During these years the government refused passports to individuals who wouldn't cooperate with Congressional committees. The key issue was whether travel was a right or a privilege. After eight years of litigation, in a case argued before the Supreme Court, Boudin secured the right of the individual to travel.

"People call me radical, though I don't know why," he says. "I'm really not political. In fact I have a basic cynicism for any political line because I don't know where the truth is."

While he claims not to be a political person, throughout his long career he has associated with people on the left end of America's political spectrum.

In the 1940s he joined the National Lawyer's Guild, instead of the American Bar Association, which opposed much of the New Deal legislation at the time. While many of the lawyers left the Guild for fear of being branded communist, Boudin stayed on. And he admits his decision to drop Chile as a client after the military coup this fall was more than just a coincidence.

The man drives himself. He often will spend 18 hours a day working. And he plays hard. Without any prompting he'll tell you how good he is in his weekly tennis matches.

Today Boudin is probably most widely known for his defense of Ellsberg. As he discusses the trial you get a peek into the many facets of the man's personality. There is Boudin the social wit: "Everyone makes leaks when they want to--Kissinger leaks, Ehrlichman leaks, the Justice Department leaks, government clerks leak, but when Ellsberg leaks everyone makes a big deal." As he finishes, he slowly breaks into a smile--deadpan is not one of his fortes.

And there is Boudin the careful attorney. When asked about a recent Harper's article which paints an unflattering picture of Ellsberg, his face clouds. "I'd never criticize a client...there are things I don't like about Ellsberg and there are undoubtably things he doesn't like about me. There are certain idiosvncracies he has, but he's a hero, and that's part of a person of heroic stature."

"Me? I'm too old to have heroes. But if I had to pick one it would be Clarence Darrow--he was above politics.

"I like to defend people against the government. It's been said before, but if there's one thing this country is great for it's respect for individual rights."

Advertisement