New York, N.Y.— Harvard alumni may have skated to a 7-0 win at the Chelsea Piers Sky Rink Saturday morning, but their undergraduate counterparts would not have their way with Yale that night at the World’s Most Famous Arena.

In the first-ever Rivalry On Ice game, the No. 10 Yale men’s hockey team cruised to a 5-1 win in front of 15,524 at Madison Square Garden. A three-goal Bulldog outburst over a span of three minutes early in the second period left Harvard deflated and its senior starting goaltender on the bench.

Yale (8-3-4, 3-2-3 ECAC) converted on three of four straight shots on goal in the middle frame, starting with a slapshot at the right point from sophomore Cody Learned at 2:35. The Bulldogs scored on their next shot on goal with a long-distance marker from senior defender Gus Young, and Learned poked his second of the night past senior goaltender Raphael Girard’s pads less than 30 seconds later. The score put Yale up, 4-1, and prompted Harvard coach Ted Donato ’91 to swap Girard for junior goaltender Steve Michalek.

“Quite frankly, we didn’t have all 20 guys,” Donato said. “The first goal [in the second period] kind of knocked us off balance, and we weren’t able to truly recover.”

For Harvard (5-8-3, 2-6-3 ECAC), it all unraveled too quickly. The Crimson could not respond to the defending national champion’s 1-2-3 punch.

While the Rivalry On Ice’s result will not count toward the ECAC conference standings, the anticipation leading up to this game rivaled its football counterpart.  Saturday’s match-up promised to be the first in an annual series of games that Harvard and Yale will play in New York City.

Crimson and Bulldog alumni gathered for events throughout the city on Saturday to celebrate the teams’ first meeting in Madison Square Garden in over 40 years. National Hockey League legend Mark Messier promoted the event in the days leading up to the Rivalry, and Secretary of State John Kerry was on hand for the ceremonial puck drop. Harvard and Yale wore special throwback uniforms for the occasion. At the conclusion of the game, Messier presented Yale with a game trophy at center ice.

“We got treated like pros all weekend,” Harvard sophomore forward Jimmy Vesey said. “I don’t know if any of us will ever play at MSG again, so it was truly a once in a lifetime experience.”

In the opening frame, Yale controlled the play early before Harvard entered the first intermission with the momentum seemingly on its side.

Sophomore center Stu Wilson connected with freshman forward Mike Doherty in the crease 4:23 into the game to put the Bulldogs up one. Wilson drove past the Harvard goal line on the right side before dropping the puck to Doherty for a one-timer past Girard.

Vesey responded minutes later with a one-timer of his own. After junior defender Pat McNally drew a tripping minor from senior forward Kenny Agostino for the game’s first power play ten minutes into the frame, freshman Luke Esposito set up behind the Yale goal line on the right wing and found Vesey with a well-timed crossing feed to beat freshman goaltender Alex Lyon.

Vesey’s team-leading tenth goal marked a brief Crimson surge as Harvard finished the period controlling the play and outshooting Yale, 14-12.

“I think in the second half of the first period we kind of took the game over a bit,” Donato said. “We used our speed, and [Lyon] made a couple of big saves to keep it at 1-1.”

But the Crimson’s fortunes turned on a bounce in the second.

In Harvard’s last game against Yale—a 2-2 tie on Dec. 7—Girard had a career-high 52 saves—the most by a Crimson goaltender in 29 years. Saturday was a different story as the senior struggled to track the puck from the blueline.