To the editors:
I’ve just seen the CNN article about the Holocaust-denier ad and note that “Al Tompkins, a faculty member at the Poynter Institute, ... said he hopes this will become a ‘teachable moment.’” It seems to me that it is also an opportunity for a premier college newspaper to apply skills for investigative journalism that are increasingly disappearing from mainstream print media. What are responsible academic researchers finding out about the motivation and mechanism of such “denial” movements, including denials of the Holocaust, the “birther” movement, and so many more? Do these movements get more visibility or involvement in hard economic straits? What approaches have all media taken to “denial” ads, and with what results? Are “tea party”-type naysayers and shouters denialists, or are they engaged in vigorous public debate?
By focusing on the one ad, even if it is to criticize it, we give its sponsor too much airtime and give the public too little perspective. With a good follow-up story about both the imperfection of running a newspaper and the minuscule role of deniers in the larger scheme of things, The Crimson would do a great service.
I believe that the health of a society depends in large part on citizen’s intelligent skepticism—unwillingness to merely accept what is put before it as “gospel” (e.g., there are weapons of mass destruction in Iraq because there must be, or because it is “obvious,” or because Saddam says so; ...) and demanding more and better evidence. But there ought to be an articulatable and reasoned distinction between such wise and helpful skepticism and obsessive and irrational denialism.
Stephen M. Jacoby
Croton-on-Hudson, N.Y.
September 14, 2009
Read more in Opinion
Thanks, But No ThanksRecommended Articles
-
Obligations of the PressIn Tuesday’s Crimson, an advertisement was published that questioned the occurrence of the Holocaust. Understandably, the advertisement offended large segments
-
Hillel Speaker Talks About Holocaust DenialHarvard Hillel invited guest speaker Dr. Deborah E. Lipstadt, a prominent opponent of Holocaust deniers, to join a discussion about ...
-
Gore's Latest Book Focuses on SolutionsFormer Vice President Al Gore ’69 spoke to a packed audience about his latest book “Our Choice: A Plan To ...
-
The Chai Party MovementIn the past year, two very different democracies have given birth to eerily similar movements.
-
Sound Bites: Professors on the Occupy Boston Movement
-
Why Can’t We Be Friends?There is little room in the blogosphere for another comparison of Occupy Wall Street and the Tea Party movement, but echoes resound in the empty space where neutral constructive criticism might be found.