To the editors:
I was first astonished, then outraged, and finally saddened by The Harvard Crimson’s story of September 29 about e-mail messages to Harvard College students from a former graduate student in the Economics Department. It is hard for me to believe that anyone who reads these e-mails, or the former student’s blog, will take the allegations they contain as seriously as The Crimson seems to do.
The Crimson appears to be utterly unaware of the commitment to students that has led my Economics Department colleagues and the university administration to remain silent about this affair. There are strict rules governing the privacy of students with respect to medical and administrative matters. These rules, which are intended to protect vulnerable individuals, make it impossible to discuss the reasons why, to quote your article, the former student “said she was required to take an involuntary medical leave of absence on Aug. 9, 2007, and was required to withdraw from GSAS at the Aug. 31 Administrative Board meeting this year.”
Readers of The Crimson should know that Professor Kenneth Rogoff, a particular target of the e-mails, has handled this matter with consummate professionalism, consulting the university administration at every stage. The e-mail from Professor Rogoff quoted in the Crimson story used text suggested to him by GSAS administrators. Deans Michael Smith and Allan Brandt have expressed their strong support in a recent letter to Professor Rogoff, which states “the allegations about your conduct, described in the article and the mounting mass emails, were without any substance” and concludes, “You are, and always have been, an upstanding member of our community, a wonderful colleague, and a valuable mentor to many students.”
I strongly support Harvard’s commitment, quoted in the Crimson story, to “not condone or tolerate harassment—physically, verbally, or electronically—of any member of our community.” It saddens me that The Crimson has chosen to contribute to harassment rather than to oppose it.
John Y. Campbell
Cambridge, Mass.
Read more in Opinion
Selling the 'Natural'Recommended Articles
-
Ex-Grad Student Alleges MisconductA former graduate student’s mass e-mail to hundreds of College students alleging “administrative misconduct” at Harvard sparked heated debate over undergraduate e-mail lists Friday about discrimination on campus.
-
Harvard Professors Discuss Financial Crisis -
Kenneth Rogoff Talks China Economics -
Comedian Lewis Black Stresses Need for Passion in CareerGrammy Award-winning comedian Lewis N. Black stressed the importance of pursuing one’s passions at a “Conversations with Kirkland” event on Monday afternoon, including fits of laughter along the way.
-
Rogoff Awarded for Work on SecuritiesEconomics Professor Kenneth S. Rogoff received further recognition for his best-selling analysis of financial crises in early January when he was awarded the fifteenth annual TIAA-CREF Paul A. Samuelson Award for Outstanding Scholarly Writing on Lifelong Financial Security.
-
Rogoff Receives Prize for ResearchEconomics Professor Kenneth S. Rogoff received the Deutsche Bank Prize in Financial Economics last Thursday for his contributions to the field of international finance and macroeconomics.
