Students seeking a nip of gin or an advertised party will have to look
outside Harvard’s 12 undergraduate Houses after administrators
presented a new standard alcohol policy for the College yesterday.
University Hall officials unveiled a new document before the
Committee on House Life yesterday, stopping the days of hard alcohol at
House Committee’s (HoCo) stein clubs, ending advertising for private
parties, and moving up—by as much as three weeks—the date by which all
parties must be registered with houses.
New mandates include the presence of a Beverage Authorization
Team or police detail at all registered parties serving alcohol and
greater oversight by House masters and tutors.
Prior to the measure’s enactment, alcohol protocol varied
greatly among the Houses. The document was presented at the meeting as
a collaborative effort between the College Dean’s office, the Office of
General Counsel, HoCo’s, and House masters.
EVERY TUB ON ITS OWN BOTTOM
Administrators and students agreed that there was a need for
consistent standards while maintaining the House’s autonomy and their
traditional sense of community.
“We currently have 15 different standards, but they need to be
more consistent because the law is the same everywhere,” said Associate
Dean for Residential Life Suzy M. Nelson. “We wanted to align Houses to
fit within certain parameters.”
Adams House master Sean G. Palfrey ’67 said that while the
Massachusetts state law is invariable, its application in the College’s
House system must not hamper the Houses’ distinct environments.
“The way we actually do things within a family should be a little different,” he said. “We do want some flexibility.”
According to UC Vice President, Randall S. Sarafa ’09, portions
of the document are vague and invite the potential for drastically
different interpretations, thus defeating the document’s central aim of
standardizing the house’s policies.
For example, the document stipulates that tutors and other
House staff members must “check in” on private parties at least once
during the course of the night.
“I could see the potential for misinterpretation of that
clause,” he said “In some Houses, a House master...might interpret that
to be knocking on the door, turning on the lights, and walking around.”
The restrictions have already caused some perturbed reactions
among students. Controversy has been brewing in Mather House this week
over the new restrictions on advertising private parties.
“This came as a huge surprise to the upperclassmen, especially
for the seniors who are accustomed to [the email list] Mather-open as a
[place for] open discourse,” said Matthew R. Greenfield ’08 who sent a
letter of protest over the House open list after the policies were
announced.
“As a community of friends we use Mather-open to invite friends and neighbors to the goings on of the House.”
ENFORCEMENT WORRIES
The newest change by the College administration is the latest
in a slew of alcohol-related policy changes that are designed to more
strictly regulate alcohol use, and may reflect a shift away in the
balance between encouraging responsible drinking habits while avoiding
the legal woes that stem from underage alcohol consumption.
“Harvard is an educational institution, and we want to help
people learn,” said Palfrey of the need to ease the transition from
alcohol abstinence to legal drinking.
Although the document is a “working draft” and not officially
in the College’s Handbook for Students—which outlines guidelines for
student behavior at the College—Nelson, the associate dean, said that
the purpose of the policy is to clarify the legal ramifications for
both the students and the administration.
“It is the students hosting the parties who will be responsible,” she said.
UC President Matthew L. Sundquist ’09 expressed concern that
students might be unfairly held accountable to the unofficial document.
“How do you enforce a rule that’s not a part of the handbook
yet?” he asked. “You have policies that are part of the working draft
which are at odds with what’s in the student handbook.”
The measure will be voted on by the Faculty Council, the
governing body of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences. If the policy is
adopted, it will be added to the handbook.
—Staff Writer Abby D. Phillip can be reached at adphill@fas.harvard.edu.
—Staff Writer Charles J. Wells can be reached at wells2@fas.harvard.edu.
Read more in News
Facebook Grants Deletion PermissionRecommended Articles
-
Alcohol Subject Of VoteA bill advocating the relaxation of Harvard's alcohol policy by allowing Houses to co-sponsor parties will be voted on by
-
The People’s PartyApril is the cruelest month. In assigning next year’s housing, House lotteries will inevitably find ways to satisfy their seniors,
-
Alcohol ObscurityStudents wishing to hold a party might expect to consult the Student Handbook, or another official University document, to find
-
Alcohol Policy Spurs Confusion in DunsterThe “working draft” of the College-wide alcohol policy announced this past February became the subject of even more confusion earlier
-
College Ups House Funding Through Pilot Program