It takes more than a History degree from one of the world’s top
Universities to get a ticket for the (very) limited performances of
Alan Bennett’s latest, “The History Boys.” After reading at both
Cambridge and Oxford, Bennett’s first stage play—“Forty Years
On”—debuted back the revolutionary days of ‘68. However, various
critics have considered his recent take on elite schools and education
the pinnacle of his career. Judging by the widespread acclaim and the
myriad of Tony awards received a couple of weeks ago, they are spot on.
But for anyone with the slightest contact with our alma mater,
“The History Boys” becomes much more than a 2004 London West End hit
transplanted onto Broadway. In the context of the Thatcherite eighties,
the play focuses around eight students from a north English grammar
school seeking admission to the world’s most exclusive and competitive
educational institutions. Pressured from the school administration and
attracted primarily by the behemoth of reputation, they linger at
school beyond their final examinations for extra classes in preparation
for admission interviews and papers.
Although the play is primarily a comedy, Bennett’s lines
require an audience of literati. In just under three hours, spectators
will hear about Orwell’s social theory, Wittgenstein’s philosophy, a
handful of Auden, the unavoidable Shakespeare, and others. All of this
fits in the seemingly unavoidable duel between two styles of teaching
set up by Bennett.
As Teacher of General (and indefinable) Studies, the
character Hector draws heavily from Robin Williams in “Dead Poets
Society”; an old-fashioned academic armed with the appropriate
quotations for any circumstance. He does not lose sleep over the
students’ struggle to again admission to Oxbridge, as he considers
testing (and education itself) an enemy of true education. As the
hatefully pragmatic principal describes, Hector’s contribution to the
students’ characters is “unquantifiable, and thus purposeless in
education.”
Opposed to him we find a Machiavellian younger professor, Dr.
Irwin, hired by the administration to get the students into the elite
institutions. Irwin seeks to avoid clichés and trite essays,
emphasizing that the “old ways” produce only “dull” essays. History
(and academia, for that matter) is nowadays “entertainment,” where
“facts are just the beginning,” according to Irwin.
His creative but confrontational approach to history, as well
as his popular British television documentaries, illustrate Bennet’s
charges against proud academics. Although his academic criticism is at
times too simplistic to be taken seriously, Bennett ends up heightening
Irwin’s role in developing the students’ personalities as the character
deals with his own inner conflicts.
The synthesis of Hector’s quotes and Irwin’s awakening of
historical passion meet with a third teacher, Mrs. Lindtott,
masterfully portrayed by Frances de la Tour. Although she represents
the epitome of the classic way, the only woman in the cast successfully
develops both the wittiest humor and a profound emotional entanglement
with the audience.
The play’s radical combination of filmed segments, an
engaging score, and flawless stage-managing prove director Nicholas
Hytener’s holistic vision for the play was aesthetically worthy of
Bennet’s dialogue.
“The History Boys” does not have one theme; its profundity
lies in dealing with an eclectic but complimentary variety of issues,
all of which relate to elite education. Bennett’s play addresses
homosexuality, and literature’s raison d’ être; it analyzes legacies,
but also the understandability of the Holocaust; it tries to define
money’s role in education while addressing gender neutrality and
manliness.
With a heavily British accent, “The History Boys” achieves
what only masterful art can: a diverse but cohesive critique of
education and its meaning. After witnessing these students’ dreams of
Oxbridge, it is left to the spectator to ponder over the “confusion of
a real education with cold, ancient cobblestone.” A sublime opposition
in their, yet also our, Cambridge.
—Staff writer Pierpaolo Barbieri can be reached at barbier@fas.harvard.edu.
Read more in Arts
Grads Grow A Tasty ‘Tomato’