Mark Mazzoleni is going home—and not to his house in New Hampshire.

After five years in Cambridge, Mazzoleni resigned as Harvard men’s hockey coach on June 16 to return to his native Wisconsin, accepting the top spot behind the bench with the Green Bay Gamblers of the United States Hockey League (USHL).

Professionally, the move from the collegiate ranks to junior hockey is a step backward for Mazzoleni, who in his five seasons at the helm guided the Crimson to an 82-72-13 record—highlighted by three consecutive trips to the NCAA tournament and ECAC postseason titles in 2002 and 2004—and restored Harvard to national prominence following four consecutive losing seasons under his predecessor, Ronn Tomassoni.

Only four other schools have gone to the NCAA tournament each of the past three seasons.

“This is a big loss for Harvard,” Director of Athletics Robert Scalise said in a press release announcing Mazzoleni’s resignation. “Looking back, one can see that he has really done an outstanding job with our hockey program, and I am really proud of what he has done here.”

Scalise did not respond to several requests for further comment.

But despite his successes at Harvard, Mazzoleni never quite found his niche in Massachusetts, limited in his adjustment by the same Midwestern sensibility and style that often set him at odds with players and their parents. Mazzoleni also remained decidedly aloof from the campus, choosing to live with his wife and children in New Hampshire for financial reasons, even if it meant a long daily commute to Bright Hockey Center.

Still, little indicated that Mazzoleni and Harvard would part ways prior to his final year. The Crimson entered the 2003-2004 campaign ranked sixth in the nation and was regarded as the hands-down favorite to capture the ECAC title after posting a 22-10-2 mark the season before. Mazzoleni had personally improved from the fourth choice for his position in 1999 to the recipient of a multi-year contract extension, and carried Scalise’s blessing, despite the widely-speculated misgivings of a small circle of team parents and alumni.

Early inconsistency, however, sent Harvard tumbling from the polls and unleashed a series of background grumblings from that group, muted only by the seven straight wins that propelled the Crimson to the ECAC crown. Harvard’s third-period collapse against Maine in the first round of the NCAA tournament—a disappointing exit, given the high expectations carved out prior to the season—reignited those criticisms.

“I honestly don’t think [those complaints] had any role in his decision,” captain Noah Welch said. “We had meetings and stuff and at the end of the discussions, the athletics department always stood behind him and so did the team.”

Still, Mazzoleni conceded that he was cognizant of the critiques circulating primarily via internet message boards despite his best efforts to look the other way.

“I’m human,” Mazzoleni said. “I don’t read the stuff but I have friends that know me and in every group you have people who read it and forward it and I’ve had a couple sent to me.”

“If I wanted to respond to something, I’m not going to get on the internet or ask someone to post a response for me [because] that’s not a credible source for me to respond to,” he added. “To analyze me by what people say over the internet—that’s so unfair.”

When the University of Wisconsin brought former Green Bay head coach Mark Osiecki on board to fill a recently vacated assistant’s position, Mazzoleni’s name quickly surfaced among the frontrunners to replace him, thanks in large part to his longstanding friendship with the Gamblers’ president, Rob Nicholson.

Both Mazzoleni—a former goaltender for Michigan State and long-time Packers season ticket holder—and his wife still have family in the Green Bay area, furthering suspicion that, should an offer be made, Harvard might be searching for a new coach. Those inklings were confirmed following Mazzoleni’s trip to Wisconsin the weekend prior to his resignation, with reports of a contract offer leaking not long after his arrival.