The staff fails to perceive the difference between needless provocation of China (such as Bush’s use of the word “competitor”) and prudent, principled disagreement. By its logic, Taiwan needs no military whatsoever, since the United States is pledged to defend it. Why let the Taiwanese defend themselves if we can send American soldiers no older than the staff to die in their place?
Military planning must always be for the worst-case scenario, not for a world where every country acts as expected. We may expect that China would never invade Taiwan, but our expectations are unlikely to give the Taiwanese nearly so much comfort as Aegis radar the next time China conducts missile exercises off the Taiwan coast. The submarines are similarly a defensive weapon against invasion—Taiwan is not in a position to attack the mainland. It would be irresponsible to leave Taiwan defenseless when it faces such a powerful and aggressive threat.
The U.S. may publicly maintain the farce of One China for diplomatic reasons, but that does not mean that the democratically elected government of Taiwan is any less legitimate, nor does it have any less right to defend itself. The U.S. should not give China veto power over the quality of Taiwan’s defenses.
— David M. DeBartolo ’03, Stephen E. Sachs ’02
Read more in Opinion
Grafton, We Hardly Knew YeRecommended Articles
-
Taiwan Not a TerritoryTo the editor: Carine M. Williams' article titled "Taiwanese Official Lauds U.S. Relations" (Oct. 30) fails to emphasize that representative
-
Law Students to Monitor Taiwanese ElectionsEven as China begins full-scale military exercises in the Taiwan Strait, a delegation of 12 Law School students is preparing
-
Groups Sponsor Pro-Democracy DemonstrationMore than 100 people gathered on the steps of Memorial Church yesterday to voice their support for Taiwan's democracy. Amid
-
Delicate Work Ahead on ChinaThese are the times that try diplomats' souls. Two days after relations between the United States and China were reported
-
Bridging the Two ChinasT he following might be just too horrifying and dangerous for some to depict in their minds. But the folks
-
In Taipei, Law School Grad Beats Public Health AlumPopular incumbent and Harvard Law School graduate Ying-jeou Ma won the Taipei mayoral election decisively Saturday, positioning him to be