Pity the Poor Little PlutocratsTo the editors:
Woe to the wealthy! At least that's what the dimmer readers of "The Income Tax Conspiracy" by Jason L. Steorts '03 (Opinion, March 7) might be tempted to yell. The brighter bulbs, however, can recognize it for the inanity it is.
His point about progressive taxation imposing a double penalty upon the wealthy should never have gotten past the editors. What is implied is that under a flat tax the rich would have the special penalty of paying more money than the poor. Is this the "first" penalty for being rich? Steorts implies that a just tax system, without special penalties, would have each person pay the same amount. If a single mother earns $20,000, and a rich banker earns $200,000, then each of them paying $10,000 is not just cause for the mother to complain: them's the breaks.
But what about that "extra" penalty that progressive taxation imposes upon the wealthy? He seems to think that it's just poor people hating their betters (to use his words, "those who [are] good at what they do").
I don't know if Steorts has ever met any poor people, but money is far more important to the poor than the rich. For the rich, an extra tax might mean vacation in Rio instead of Paris. For the poor, an extra tax might mean that mother has to choose between heat in winter and health insurance for her children.
The notion that the rich, even with those burdensome progressive taxes, are dealt with unfairly is nonsense.
Glenn Kinen '02
Read more in Opinion
Outrageous OutrageRecommended Articles
-
Deciding the City's Foreign Policy And Other Weighty MattersQUESTION #1 "Shall the city of Cambridge be authorized to tax real estate located in the city and owned by
-
All-Ivy Council Discusses Common IssuesThe spirit of competition between the eight schools of the Ivy League will probably always be fierce. But this weekend,
-
Poison Ivy?This year's Undergraduate Council is tightening its belt in almost every area. Due to budget shortages, the council only gives
-
Free Trade's Next Frontier"New" Democrats have made a name for themselves as proponents of free trade. Their reign gave rise to NAFTA and
-
Tax Rate to Rise by $8; Vellucci: 'Dig Up Yard'Cambridge's tax rate will probably rise by at least $8 this year, Acting City Manager Ralph J. Dunphy told the
-
City Council Ups Cambridge Tax Rate 20 PercentThe City Council last night voted into effect a 20 percent increase in the average residential tax rate as part