In his April 4 letter, Undergraduate Council President Noah Z. Seton '00 tries to deflect criticism of his administration, specifically regarding the recent ROTC bill. But in defending himself, Seton seriously mischaracterizes both the nature of the debate and the content of the final bill.
Although Seton claims that the bill was not meant to be apolitical, supporters of the bill referred several times to efforts to depoliticize the bill. They repeatedly claimed that the bill was about student services, rather than political issues.
Seton further writes that the final version of the bill contains language condemning the military's so-called "don't ask, don't tell" policy of excluding homosexuals from serving openly in the military. In fact, the council rejected a strongly worded amendment that would have explicitly condemned the policy. Instead, the final bill merely states that the council does not endorse the military's exclusionary policy. It does not contain a condemnation.
The most disturbing characteristics of the recent council debate, and the current administration, are not that the council is truly depoliticized. Rather, the council tries to disguise conservative political statements in apolitical language. The ROTC bill clearly contradicts Harvard's nondiscrimination policy and is a strong political statement that military recruitment on campus is more important than protection of homosexuals from discrimination at Harvard.
David B. Orr '01
April 14, 1999
Coverage of Erotica Event Inaccurate
Read more in Opinion
So Long, RadcliffeRecommended Articles
-
Term Bill Fee Hike Will Face Student ReferendumConsidering what Harvard students and their parents pay for tuition, the Undergraduate Council is hoping they won't mind an extra
-
Progressivism Splits Seton, RedmondLess than 20 years old, the Undergraduate Council is experiencing that typical teenage angst--an identity crisis. A debate that many
-
Keep ROTC Off CampusHarvard students in the military's Reserve Officer Training Corps (ROTC) program have not been able to take their classes on
-
LettersStudent Services and Politics Do Co-Exist on the Council To the editors: I am writing to offer a clarification of
-
Council Swiftly Tackles Long DocketThe Undergraduate Council tackled its longest docket in recent memory last night and still made it home almost in time
-
Council Closes Out the TermWith ROTC, downsizing and divestment finally set aside, the members of the Undergraduate Council largely focused on congratulating themselves last
