To the editors:
I must admit that after reading "The Bee: A Club of Their Own" (News, Feb. 17), my opinion of the club has changed for the better. While it is clear that there exists a discrepancy between the intellectual and emotional depth of the club as reported by its members and by those women punched who did not finally join, and while one may certainly charge that the organization fosters elitism and merely pays lip-service to the importance of diversity, have not most academic institutions been accused--and found guilty--of these same things?
I don't mean to imply that this is excusable, but perhaps we're pointing our fingers in the wrong direction.
What strikes me most is the relative awareness and legitimacy of the Bee as compared to its all-male counterparts. The Bee's tradition of donating a book to the group's collection moves in the direction of an intellectualism eschewed by the final clubs. The effort (transparent as it may be) to encourage diversity betrays some vague awareness of reality that stands out in stark comparison to that held by Douglas Sears '69, president of the Interclub Council, who legitimizes the final clubs by maintaining, "Men have always wanted a place of their own where they wouldn't have to compete with women."
What perplexes me is that in the face of such rock-and-roll feminist epithets as, "It was so great to see women controlling the liquor...playing pool instead of watching men play pool," the group still aligns itself with the all-male final clubs. If Sears' comment is any indication of the historic and prevailing final club attitude toward women ("We tried to get them to understand what goes into running a club. We tried to explain to them that being a landlord is no fun at all"), why, women of the Bee, do you have tea at the Fly as a punch event?
Clearly you need not rely on a tradition that represents all that is objectionable and harmful about Harvard--a tradition whose condescension extends to doubting your ability to be a landlord and assuring you, in the tone of your most patronizing kindergarten teacher, that owning your own building would just be "no fun at all." Come on, girls, you're smarter than that. And best of luck with your club. JESSICA A. NORDELL '99 Feb. 18, 1998
Read more in Opinion
Lewis Trumps ValuesRecommended Articles
-
Graduate Council Bans Beer Kegs at Final ClubsThe graduate board presidents of Harvard's eight final clubs voted unanimously this summer--as part of sweeping reforms in the clubs'
-
Clubs Limit Guests to Curb RisksAfter almost two decades at the center of Harvard's party scene four of the eight all-male final clubs have returned
-
Officials, Students Debate Social SceneSince final clubs began formally barring non-members in January, Dean of the College Harry R. Lewis '68 has made a
-
Spee Final Club Decides to Close Its Doors to Non-MembersThe Spee final club has decided to bar all non-members from entering the club, no exceptions, effective last Thursday. Spee
-
Final Clubs On a Short LeashIn April of 1998, graduate members of the Phoenix S.K. final club heard a nasty rumor. Undergraduate members, it seemed,
-
Bee Expands MembershipThe Bee, an all-female social club, admitted new members to its ranks for the first time just before winter break,