Empty stores with dark interiors flank the sidewalks of Central Square like missing teeth. Banners announce the relocation of stores that have proudly stood at the intersection of Mass. Ave. and Magazine Street for decades.
The Holmes Realty Trust is poised to demolish this Central Square property. But conflict over the architecture of the building that will rise in place of these stores stopped the wrecking ball in its tracks earlier this month.
Holmes, a family owned business which has owned the property in question since 1915, wants to knock down the existing building and construct a new, more expensive complex for mixed residential and commercial use. The proposed complex--composed of two different buildings--will be 120,000 square feet and 60 to 70 feet at its tallest point, according to Holmes's attorney James J. Rafferty.
Originally the building was to have 12 stories, but the Cambridge Planning Board forced Holmes to scale down the design to seven stories.
The plans have been hotly debated from the start.
Many Cantabrigians say the new building is another step in the highly contested gentrification of Cambridge--and more specifically of Central Square--claiming that renovated facades and more upscale restaurants and stores have and will continue to make rents in the Square rise and drive residents from the area as a result.
The new Holmes plans do not conform to Cambridge zoning laws and, therefore, must be approved by the Cambridge Planning Board. The proposed height and square footage of the building exceeds zone limits, according to Scott Levitan, a member of the Central Square Advisory Committee (CSAC).
The city has dragged its feet
"It's a total embarrassment to anyone in myindustry that a city could be so poorly run toallow such a transgression of the developmentprocess," Pratt says. "It's ridiculous."
Holmes first presented its plans to cityagencies at a meeting in March of last year.
Since then, Holmes has redesigned its plansseveral times per the city's request. On Feb. 3Holmes was again forced by the Planning Board torevise its plans.
Members of the Cambridge community developmentdepartment say their concerns lie with theaesthetics of the building and any changes it maybring to the feel of the Square.
"The Board members indicated their points ofview on the design and asked that the developmentshift in height away from the Karl Baron Plaza,"says Lester W. Barber, director of land use andzoning in Cambridge's Community DevelopmentDepartment.
The Board members also requested that thedevelopers redesign the interior courtyard thatlinks the two buildings of the complex, Barbersays.
"The Planning Board members felt that thedesign of the development has negative impacts onthe location in Central Square," says Liza M.Paden, assistant land use planner for theCommunity Development Department.
The Board must ensure that the developmentmeets the overlay district guidelines under which"the development must look like it belongs inCentral Square and fits in the fabric of CentralSquare," according to Paden.
Read more in News
Basketball Team Tops Green, 76-72, After Leading by 49-31 at Half-TimeRecommended Articles
-
Groups Oppose Coffee ChainIn the continuing battle between chain stores and watchdog groups over the fate of Harvard Square, the Harvard Square Defense
-
Living Where Some See Only MoneyT he bulldozers are gunning their engines, ready to level the heart of Central Square as soon as the remaining
-
Let the Market Do Its WorkI am going to say something that will shock many people living in the city of Cambridge: the United States
-
THE SQUARE DEALRead Block, a collection of buildings at the center of Harvard Square that once housed The Tasty, will soon be
-
Big Names Leave No Space for Mom and PopThe future is Abercrombie & Fitch. While city activists clamor to protect the distinctiveness of the Square, chain stores are
-
Central Square Renovations Permitted Despite ProtestsAfter heated debate, the City of Cambridge's Planning Board granted Holmes Real Estate Trust permission to renovate Central Square. Holmes