It appears that there are some kinds of hate speech that are acceptable at Harvard.
William P. Moynihan '00 reports that a student named "[Edidiong N.] Ikpe '00 said it is possible [Janice] George was mentally unstable." ("Students Befriend a Fraud," news story, Sept. 24). What does mental instability have to do with deception? It is more likely that a psychologist would deceive someone. Attributing mental illness is an effective way to discredit someone as Ikpe has done.
On Sept. 18, 1996, The Crimson reported an Associated Press story about a shooting at Pennsylvania State University, noting of the 19-year-old woman suspect: "acquaintances said [she] had a history of mental problems and once spent time in a hospital."
What is the connection between mental illness and criminal violence? Is it fear in the minds of reporters, students and law enforcement authorities? All too often a person's alleged mental illness is used as evidence of guilt when charged with a crime. Bias against persons considered to be mentally ill pervades society.
We hear about discrimination against gays, women, blacks and Jews regularly in the media and the courts. But it is still acceptable to discriminate against persons considered to be mentally ill, to harass them and to utter hate speech about them in polite company--even at Harvard University, a stronghold of political correctness. Are some kinds of hate speech good? What is the difference?
It is illegal to hate Jews and blacks in America. Persons alleged to be mentally ill are treated the same today as they were during the Inquisition. --Roy Bercaw, Cambridge
Read more in Opinion
Tenure Process Works WellRecommended Articles
-
Depression More Than Just A Feeling of SadnessTo the editors: I was impressed by the sympathetic coverage of the recent alleged crime of violence against a female
-
Mentally Ill Students Marginalized and TrivializedUpon opening October 3rd's Crimson, an article entitled "Sitcom Schizophrenia Seizez HRDC" caught my eye. I read the article carefully,
-
Please Learn About the Mentally IllI am a seriously mentally ill man. I wish to inform Harvard students of general information concerning mental illness. Today,
-
When's the Last Time You Heard a Ventalin joke?I would like to express my respect for Allison Kent '99 and commend her courage for her letter "Mentally Ill
-
Psychiatrist Szasz Contends Mental Illness Does not Exist"Institutional psychiatry should be regarded as a threat to your freedom." Dr. Thomas S. Szasz, a professor of Psychiatry at
-
Depression: A Personal AccountF or many years I have suffered from a chronic depressive illness in cycles of varying intensity and duration. Although