With all the weeping, wailing and gnashing of teeth heard all across the campus recently, you'd think that Harvard students heard stallions braying and trampling hooves pounding on asphalt as the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse gallopped up J.F.K. Street. But their cause for alarm was actually Harvard's slip from first to third place in the annual U.S. News and World Report college rankings. Apparently, students at Stanford are also reacting hysterically to their tumble from fourth to sixth place.
A Stanford-led coalition of college students is now attempting to force U.S. News and World Report to abandon its rankings or switch to a system that groups top schools together. The coalition wants colleges and universities to withhold data from the magazine until it reforms its list. Nothing could be more ridiculous.
At Harvard, a movement to support this coalition may be starting. Apparently students at Yale and Princeton are expressing interest as well, although I'd bet that their interest stems from polite false humility and that they won't be too active in the crusade to dump the rankings. Although one of the organizers of the Stanford coalition denies that this movement stems from "sour grapes," it's pretty clear that bitter envy is the driving force behind the effort to reform the rankings. Had Stanford been ranked number one, no one from Stanford would be whining.
Of course the rankings are pretty subjective, as the critics claim. But U.S. News and World Report perennially ranks services and institutions from hospitals to mutual funds and they should continue to make up lists as they see fit. Opponents of the rankings also assert that they are "taken as dogma" by and exert undue influence over students, employers and the general public.
However, students at top schools such as Stanford and Harvard should not be so upset. None of them are going to be passed over for those highly competitive jobs in investment banking and consulting because Harvard is now ranked third. You won't be rejected by a top graduate school because of the U.S. News list. And if prospective students are dumb enough to pick a college based on its rank in a magazine, we don't need them here anyway. Students at Harvard and other schools should eat their pride, stop complaining and concentrate on their educations.
Read more in Opinion
Bigger Isn't BetterRecommended Articles
-
Coalition Will Try To Alter U.S. News Ranking SystemA Stanford-led coalition of students at universities across the nation is fighting to force U.S. News and World Report to
-
>Harvard Grad Schools Top U.S. News SurveyThe rankings are in, and Harvard has passed with flying colors. Today, U.S. News and World Report released its annual
-
New Aid Policies Could Affect College RankingsIf financial aid changes at Princeton, Yale and Stanford attract more students from the middle class, it could potentially have
-
Grad Schools Top US News Rankings, Stanford Closes InHarvard's medical, business and education graduate schools are the nation's finest, according to a just-released U.S. News and World Report
-
Stanford Takes Lead In New RankingsThe Medical School remained Harvard’s last hold-out as Stanford University graduate programs rose to the top in a new set
-
Three Harvard Schools Take First in U.S. RankingsThree of Harvard’s graduate schools sat at the top of their respective heaps in national rankings released last week. In