Advertisement

Local Group Claims Tests Are Biased

New Cambridge Study Cites PSAT, SAT Questions As Favoring Men Over Women

This spring, female juniors all over America are sharpening their number two pencils, placing all books and papers beneath their seats and scoring lower than their male counterparts on what many have charged are biased tests.

Over the years, women have consistently scored lower on the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) and Preliminary Scholastic Assessment Tests (PSAT) than men, from 30 to 80 points lower (within racial categories), according to The Princeton Review.

The Cambridge-based National Center of Fair and Open Testing (Fair Test) said in a study released yesterday that this difference is the result of gender biased questions. Fair Test says that this bias not only impairs fair college admissions processes, but also denies women the chance to win the financial awards offered in the National Merit Scholarship competition, since the qualification for award is based upon test scores.

"Young women lose their fair share of more than $25,000,000 in prestigious awards each year solely due to the use of a biased test," said Fair Test's Executive Director Dr. Pamela Zappardino.

According to FairTest, while 56% who took the PSAT in 1994 were female, only 42% of National Merit Semifinalists are female. Semifinalists are chosen solely on the basis of test scores.

Advertisement

Brett A. Gordon, Executive Director of the Boston Office of The Princeton Review, agrees that the tests exhibit gender bias.

"FairTest is right. The PSAT is definitely biased in favor of men and penalizes women at both SAT and PSAT levels," Gordon said.

"[Bias in the test] has a lot to do with the way questions work. Here's an analogy that's been used in the past--racquet is to tennis, as: spring board is to diving; horse is to polo;glove is to boxing; club is to golf; gun is to hunting. First, racial discrimination is a problem. I am a middle-class white male, and I know what polo is, but someone in the inner-city might not know. And like it or not, males tend to know more about sports," Gordon said.

"Math questions tend to talk about averages, and if a person knows somethingabout baseball, they will do better on thosequestions," he added.

Gordon also denounced the test for its failureto accurately predict future performance.

"Women, on average, perform one full gradepoint higher than men in college, so the testobviously cannot predict [future performance],"Gordon said.

But representatives of The College Board, theorganization that administers the PSAT and theSAT, blamed women's lower scores on poorpreparation and environmental factors, not testbias.

"The test is not biased," Assistant Director inPublic Affairs for The College Board Greg C. Busbysaid. "It is a simplistic leap to assume thatbecause girls don't score as well that the test isbiased."

"The reason [women don't do well] is that girlstend to take courses that award higher grades,like art, music and languages, and men tend totake more rigorous science and math courses,"Busby said. "Historically speaking, women havebeen encouraged to take classes like home ec,music and languages rather than science and math."

Vocabulary Scores

When asked why women don't do as well onvocabulary as men do, even though they have hadbetter preparation in languages, Busby replied:"Women do not do as well on vocabulary because menhave been exposed to more vocabulary words in theother classes. The vocab section takes vocabularyfrom all different types of curriculum."

Advertisement