Steve Calabria passed for two touchdowns and ran for another to lead Colgate (5 2) to a 35 16 win over Columbia in New York City.
With the loss, Columbia dropped to 0-6 on the year.
Calabria, who hit on 18 of 29 passes for 322 yards, hit Torn Stenglein with scoring passes of free and 37 yards in the first half and ran for Colgate's final touchdown in the fourth quarter.
Read more in Sports
Women Booters Await NCAA Bids