The discovery that important cancer experiments reported in a Ph.D. thesis at Cornell University may have been falsified has led to a major setback in cancer research, a Cornell official said last night.
"Extraordinarily important work" into how healthy cells are transformed into cancer cells may be 90 per cent false, Richard E. McCarty, chairman of Cornell's department of biochemistry, said, adding that the work "had attracted a great deal of attention."
McCarty said that Mark D. Spector, a second-year graduate student, "managed to manipulate" two professors and another graduate student working with him into arriving at "extremely exciting" but apparently contrived research results.
Spector had reported the findings in his Ph.D. thesis and contributed to articles in several prominent journals.
Scientists only began to suspect his findings when other research consistently contradicted the published reports, McCarty said.
"You have somebody like that with an absolutely brilliant mind and you don't question him." McCarty said, adding, "We did question him, but one and a half years afterwards."
Spector first defended his findings, but withdrew from Cornell after meeting with McCarty. He was unavailable for comment yesterday.
Volker M. Vogt, professor of biochemistry, who collaborated with Spector on some of the cancer experiments, said it would take a long time to repeat the work, adding, "It's difficult to repeat results that are in part correct."
"I think we are all going to look a lot more closely over our graduate students' shoulders," McCarty said.
Read more in News
The Reporter's NotebookRecommended Articles
-
Enrollment Shifts Stymie TF HiringUnpredictable changes in class enrollment this year have confounded the process of assigning section leaders for the fall semester, drawing out professors’ concerns about larger section sizes.
-
Science Gen Ed Course Exhibits Final Projects
-
PBK Changes Election ProcessThe Harvard-Radcliffe chapter of the Phi Beta Kappa Society has changed its selection process for the final round of senior elections into the organization, PBK officers announced earlier this week.
-
Stanton To Become Undergraduate Education Asst. DeanCurrier House Resident Dean Katherine Stanton will become assistant dean in the Office of Undergraduate Education on Oct. 1, replacing Logan S. McCarty, who assumed a new position directing the physical sciences on July 1.
-
Conant Prize Recognizes Creative Science ProjectsFor the first time in its over 50-year history, the James Bryant Conant Prize is being awarded to a project consisting of wood, clay, twisted wire, and beams of light rather than a collection of words on a page.
-
New MCAT Means Few ChangesIn response to proposed changes to the MCAT, faculty who teach popular pre-med courses say they are unlikely to dramatically change their course curricula.